Blog

Home / Words of Wisdom from Guruji  / Darpan  / Unravelling the Mystery of the Soul’s Existence | Guruji explains
Mystery of the Soul’s Existence

Unravelling the Mystery of the Soul’s Existence | Guruji explains

Guruji, you said Yoga is for betterment of our body, mind, self and soul. Lord Buddha has said “There is no soul, it is just a particle. After death it gets mingled with the universe and it never takes rebirth”. The great thinkers Karl Marx and Albert Einstein also said that Lord Buddha’s quote is right.

So could you unveil the hypothetical puzzle please?

Your query is very clear and simple and for me offering you clarity would have been more straight and simple. Every authentic seeker is important to me. Quoting scriptures or great names make the questions and answers both complicated. 

Since you have quoted the names of great ones from the past namely Buddha, Marx and Einstein and, when names are taken then query meanders through them who are named so the solution also needs to follow the same track to address it. That makes it a bit lengthy.

As you said it’s a puzzle. It is a puzzle for sure and when this puzzle is solved and we realise that there is Nitya Aatma then we become very peaceful inside and happy too without any reason. Because in reality, becoming happy is not dependent on any reason. But anything that happens to us is dependent on happiness essentially. But satsang & discipline is needed to experience this as it really is. 

Solving hypotheses also makes us happy but that happiness doesn’t last forever. For obvious reason of hypothesis’s being anatt. (can you guess what I would have meant by the word Anatt here?) This example I used just to indicate to you that many times different attained ones use the same word to mean and communicate entirely different things. Likewise All doesn’t mean the same thing when they say – Aatmaa. 

Cognition is a vast field where even opposites are also found to be equally true. So it boils down to each one’s real truthful experience. 

Mystery of the Soul’s Existence

For example, despite presenting so many hypotheses human cognition couldn’t agree why existence exists yet it exists. Because existence is a higher stage of consciousness than the human stage of cognition. But, suppose you ask me a counter question at this point saying that if existence is a higher stage of consciousness than the human stage of cognition then how do you know this? Or, how can you make this statement? Are you not a human yourself ? Then what will I answer other than  keeping quiet? As, in the field of cognition after a point only presence speaks while we become silent.

When we figure this out then mutual dependence (pratitya samutpaad) becomes clear and vice versa. 

Reasoning (subuddhi or buddhatva) is also a stage of consciousness only though it is higher than mind yet, it is not a very high stage. Like existence is not conditional Real Happiness also is not conditional, it doesn’t need any reason to exist, it just exists.

When we try to make happiness conditional then it reduces to something else or becomes elusive falling to lower stages of consciousness. At lower stages of consciousness the world looks sorrowful. 

Buddhism begins with this point of sorrow and offers solutions to mitigate sorrow through logic and practice both. Sanatan vision  looks at the world as essentially blissful and offers union through spontaneous remembrance (sahaj smriti) as a way to stay put in happiness. It also works as a solution in the form of various yoga-s to those who somehow fall in lower states of consciousness. This is the basic difference in the point of assumption or assuming the problem for solving it. 

Reality is indicated as something that is realised beyond the field of reasoning but being beyond the field of reasoning doesn’t mean it’s unreasonable. 

We must understand the difference between the states of consciousness transcending reason and state of consciousness in which we are unreasonable or against reasoning or transgressing reason. And we should not fall down to lower levels. We can transcend reasoning only when all reasonable questions are answered to our satisfaction. Then, the mind quietens and helps us in experiencing the truth that a part of our own being lies beyond the capacity of even the super intelligence to decipher (what to say of our capacity to decipher it-as an individual! ). This experience inclines us towards meditation and experiencing within ourselves a steady state of Quiescence & gratitude then, higher stages of yoga open up to us, transforming us into yogi-s. 

Before arriving at the stage of gratitude we see only this world which is experienced through senses, not the one that is beyond it too. 

Maybe you quoted Buddha, Einstein and Marx to give more weightage to what your query is. There was no need to do that as you (a living person) are more important to me than any incarnation of supreme consciousness who is no more embodied. And in my valuing you or any living human being more than them all, lies my respect for what they did for living beings while they were embodied. Einstein’s concern in quoting greats was different.  Einstein wrote:”What humanity owes to personalities like Buddha, Moses, and Jesus ranks for me higher than all the achievements of the enquiring and constructive mind.”

He went on to emphasise the importance of preserving the moral values these personalities gave humanity. There is a useful intellectual lesson here. Neither Einstein nor Marx should be presented as authorities who endorsed Buddha’s complete philosophy.Einstein explicitly admired Buddha as a great moral personality.Marx referred to Buddhist Śūnyatā and described Buddhism’s association with a state of nothingness in a personal letter.Neither fact establishes their acceptance of the Buddhist doctrine of Anatta.

Better you go one step further. The question for you should be whether you can investigate the nature of the Self through awareness, without prematurely arriving at a conclusion through belief irrespective of what Marx, Einstein or Buddha believed in. That would make a much more meaningful dialogue. In Buddhist tradition Anatta (anitya-ta) is seen as a topic which is beyond scope of any conclusive dialogue in baikhari bhasha. Because Buddha kept quiet on 14 questions, these are named as Avyakrut in Buddhist tradition. In essence that is only one question which has been framed in 14 ways. Buddha compares these speculative questions to a man wounded by a poisoned arrow who refuses treatment until he knows who shot it, what kind of bow was used, and what poison was applied.The man would die before obtaining all those answers.

Similarly, Buddha emphasised that the urgent task is understanding suffering, its origin, its cessation and the path to its cessation. The Buddhist way of looking at life is very practical. But most of the best words of Buddha end with “esh dhamm sanantano“ means, that’s how sanatan dharma is. And all of us know sanatan means Nitya (eternal). I hope I could walk you through the meanderings of the puzzle to see it clearly.  

-With blessings and love